Each year the coaches of the CRCA recognize the outstanding student athletes in each Division. Criteria for the award include:
- The student-athlete must meet all eligibility rules as defined by her institution.
- The student-athlete must have rowed at least 75% of the season’s races in the varsity boat
- The student-athlete must be nominated by her institution
- The Head Coach of the student-athlete’s institution must be a member in good standing of the CRCA.
All-American athletes are selected from those athletes already named First-Team All Region. Criteria considered for selection include: boat performance, nomination rank, coach’s comments, individual achievements, and 2k erg score. One coxswain is named to each team.
Division I
| First Team All-America | |
|---|---|
| Claire-Louise Bode | The Ohio State University |
| Erin Boxberger | University of Notre Dame |
| Louise Breen | Brown University |
| Maddie Cordner | University of Washington |
| Anna Dawson | Stanford University |
| Mera Dickensheets | Indiana University |
| Jessica Eiffert | University of Michigan |
| Kirstyn Goodger | University of Washington |
| Angie Gould | Princeton University |
| Jenna Gregoire | Harvard University |
| Krisztina Gyimes | University of Southern California |
| Brandy Herald | University of Virginia |
| Paparangi Hipango | University of California, Berkeley |
| Kara Kohler | University of California, Berkeley |
| Victoria Lazur | The Ohio State University, coxswain |
| Daphne Martschenko | Stanford University |
| Holly Norton | The Ohio State University |
| Bryna Oleshansky | University of Michigan |
| Kelsey Reelick | Princeton University |
| Catherine Shields | The Ohio State University |
| Muriel Solberg | Brown University |
| Meaghan Volker | University of California, Los Angeles |
| Second Team All-America | |
| Katherine Ashton | US Naval Academy |
| Ashley Baue | The Ohio State University |
| Molly Bruggeman | University of Notre Dame |
| Michelle Campbell | University of San Diego |
| Maryann Concannon | Saint Mary’s College of California |
| Constanze Duell | University of Virginia |
| Morgan Dunham | University of Louisville |
| Amanda Elmore | University of Michigan |
| Rachel Gottlieb | Brown University |
| Morgan Grastorf | University of Iowa |
| Georgia Hamilton | Syracuse University |
| Nicole Hare | Washington State University |
| Milena Heuer | Clemson University |
| Aggie Nowinski | University of California, Berkeley |
| Anne Rauschert | University of Wisconsin |
| Faith Richardson | Princeton University |
| Kate Roach | Cornell University |
| Mary Sandza | Brown University, coxswain |
| Anna Taylor | Oregon State University |
| Claire Tolson | Yale University |
| Kristy Wentzel | Stanford University |
| Ruth Whyman | University of Washington |
Division II
| First Team All-America | |
|---|---|
| Megan O’Donnell | Nova Southeastern University |
| Courtney Berger | Nova Southeastern University |
| Mary Costello | Philadelphia University |
| Leyla Dombrowski | Mercyhurst University |
| Emily Little | Western Washington University |
| Kayley Weber | Humboldt State University |
| Jamie Larrabee | Humboldt State University |
| Kristine Wright | Mercyhurst University |
| Madison Martens | University of Central Oklahoma |
| Second Team All-America | |
| Amy Robinson | Philadelphia University |
| Emily Harrington | Nova Southeastern University |
| Amy VanBuskirk | University of Central Oklahoma |
| Margaret Wilhelm | Humboldt State University |
| Kelly Peterson | University of California San Diego |
Division III
| First Team All-America | |
|---|---|
| Gabriella Bilotta | Bates College |
| Becca Kimball | Wellesley College |
| Kayla Cloud | Wesleyan University |
| Piper Sallquist | Williams College |
| Michalina Fili | Washington College |
| Nadie Reilly | William Smith College |
| Caroline Walton | Hamilton College |
| Heather Monty | Bates College |
| Kathryn Hibbard | Trinity College |
| Second Team All-America | |
| Gwendolyn Schoch | Trinity College |
| Kenzie Marshall | University of Puget Sound |
| Sophie Suechting | Colby College |
| Julie Schaeffer | Ithaca College |
| Emily Widra | University of Rochester |
| Emma Carlisle-Reske | Smith College |
| Brooke Cotta | Worcester Polytechnic Institute |
| Erika Gill | Marietta College |
| Natalie Guzikowski | Franklin and Marshall College |
